If you don't shop around for vehicle insurance, you might be losing out on hundreds of dollars in annual savings.
Did you know that the same motorist might be charged $32 per month by one insurance provider and $104 by That is supported by our vehicle insurance study, which is based on millions of quotes collected throughout the country.
Aside from the facts, the best piece of advice we can provide drivers seeking the best auto insurance prices is to shop around. There is no one insurer that will be the lowest for every driver, but our study will provide you with an excellent starting point for your search.
What Is The Most Affordable Vehicle Insurance Company?
According to our research, USAA and State Farm are the cheapest large insurers in the US. USAA charges an average of $224 for six-month insurance, which is 49% less than the national average. A six-month coverage from State Farm costs $309, which is 30% less than the national average.
Although USAA is by far the most affordable choice among major insurers, only active military members, veterans, or their families are eligible for insurance.
Farm Bureau Insurance, at $251 for a six-month insurance, and Erie, at $195, are the lowest among insurers with a smaller national reach.
These insurers may not have the same brand recognition as some of the firms you may remember from national television commercials, but they may be able to help you save money if you're seeking the best rate.
Find The Best Auto Insurance at your Location
The Three Lowest-Cost Major Automobile Insurance Providers
State Farm is the largest vehicle insurance business in the United States, offering coverage countrywide with prices that are lower than the national average in 48 states (excluding Massachusetts and Rhode Island) and Washington, D.C.
State Farm charges $309 for a six-month minimum coverage vehicle insurance policy. Furthermore, this organization has a massive network of local agents, so there is definitely a State Farm representative in your location that can assist you with a policy.
Geico is the country's second-biggest vehicle insurance company, with operations in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Geico charges $390 for six-month minimum coverage insurance.
Geico also provides one of the best pricing systems in the auto insurance industry, making it simple to receive a quick rate online and compare options.
USAA is the least expensive of these three insurers and, like Geico, operates in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. On average, minimum coverage vehicle insurance costs $223 for a six-month policy, which is by far the lowest premium. We rank USAA lowest among this three insurance since it will only accept active military personnel, veterans, and their families.
However, as the country's fifth-largest car insurance business, it serves almost as many clients as other household brands such as Allstate.
The table below compares the average six-month prices for 13 of the country's largest vehicle insurers based on internet quotations for a 30-year-old driver.
We gathered estimates from 51 insurance providers over hundreds of ZIP codes (or more) in each state to identify the lowest insurers. Major insurers are denoted by an asterisk, with major defined as offering quotations in at least 20 states.
Quotes were obtained for a hypothetical driver and policy, as detailed in our approach.
Rank |
Company |
Six-month Rate |
1 | Erie | $195 |
2 | USAA | $223 |
3 | Farm Bureau Mutual | $251 |
4 | State Farm* | $309 |
5 | American Family | $387 |
6 | Geico* | $390 |
7 | ||
8 | MetLife* | $453 |
9 | Nationwide* | $466 |
10 | Auto-Owners Insurance | $513 |
11 | Farmers* | $553 |
12 | Travelers* | $623 |
13 | Allstate* | $625 |
Asterisk-marked insurers provided quotations in at least 20 states.
Continue reading to discover our suggestions for the lowest insurance based on certain driver profiles and states.
How Your Rates With The Lowest Insurers May Vary Depending On Your Driver Profile
Your location, age, driving history, vehicle, financial profile, and, perhaps most crucially, the coverage you choose may all have an impact on your auto insurance prices. Our rates above are based on a 30-year-old motorist with a clean driving record.
We demonstrate what the five largest insurers charge when we change the example driver's age, driving record, and policy limitations in the table below.
Unless otherwise specified, all charges are for a six-month insurance with full coverage rather than minimum coverage.
What Exactly Is Comprehensive Coverage?
As may be seen:
•Younger drivers and those with a history of accidents are charged significantly more than older drivers and those with a clean record.
•Those who choose basic coverage insurance can save significantly on premiums, but they risk not being completely insured in the case of a serious accident.
State-By-State Comparison Of The Lowest-Cost Insurers
The cost of auto insurance varies substantially between states. In Utah, one firm may be pricey, while in New York, it may be affordable. Although State Farm was not the cheapest vehicle insurance provider overall, it was the most broadly available and accessible insurer, which means it operates in more than 40 states and has no qualifying limitations.
USAA was frequently the lowest choice in any given state, but its qualifying rules limited its appeal. If you qualify, you should acquire a quotation from USAA, which is accessible across the country.
In some jurisdictions, a small, local firm or affiliate may even be able to provide you with the greatest pricing. In Kentucky, Louisiana, North Carolina, and Virginia, for example, Farm Bureau members are the lowest insurance on average.
Based on our research, we've compiled a list of the cheapest insurers in each state, on average. Click on your state to receive a more detailed review of the cheapest vehicle insurance in your region.
State |
Cheapest company |
Alabama | State Farm |
Alaska | State Farm |
Arizona | Geico |
Arkansas | State Farm |
California | Geico |
Colorado | State Farm |
Connecticut | Travelers |
Delaware | State Farm |
Florida | Geico |
Georgia | State Farm |
Hawaii | Geico |
Idaho | State Farm |
Illinois | State Farm |
Indiana | Erie |
Iowa | IMT |
Kansas | State Farm |
Kentucky | Farm Bureau |
Louisiana | Farm Bureau |
Maine | MetLife |
Maryland | Erie |
Massachusetts | Citizens |
Minnesota | State Farm |
Mississippi | State Farm |
Missouri | State Farm |
Montana | State Farm |
Nebraska | State Farm |
Nevada | State Farm |
New Hampshire | State Farm |
New Jersey | State Farm |
New Mexico | State Farm |
New York | State Farm |
North Carolina | Farm Bureau |
North Dakota | American Family |
Ohio | Westfield |
Oklahoma | State Farm |
Oregon | State Farm |
Pennsylvania | Erie |
South Carolina | Geico |
South Dakota | American Family |
Tennessee | State Farm |
Texas | State Farm |
Utah | State Farm |
Vermont | State Farm |
Virginia | Farm Bureau |
Washington | State Farm |
West Virginia | State Farm |
Wisconsin | Erie |
Wyoming | State Farm |
Company Suitable For You?
We found the vehicle insurance companies with the lowest rates, but depending on a number of criteria — location, driving history, financial profile, and so on — certain insurers may be less expensive for some types of drivers than others.
•Erie: The most affordable overall corporation
•State Farm: The least expensive company after an accident
•USAA : Is the most affordable corporation for military families.
•Metromile: Is the most affordable firm for low-mileage drivers.
•Geico: The most affordable provider for individuals with a bad credit history.
These are our suggestions for the cheapest firms on average, which can help you if you're just seeking the best deal.</h5>
Compare the best vehicle insurance providers for the finest combination of pricing, customer service, and features.
Cheapest Car Insurance Provider Erie In General
Given that USAA has eligibility limits and Farm Bureau is disproportionately expensive when additional coverages are added, we rank Erie as the most affordable insurance carrier. It's also dependable, thanks to its stellar customer service reputation.
The biggest disadvantage of Erie is that it is only offered in 12 states and Washington, D.C.
Erie was one of the cheapest non-USAA alternatives for our example driver, whether you're searching for a car insurance policy that just fulfills your state needs or a more comprehensive full-coverage policy.
Companies with the lowest rates for a minimal coverage insurance
Rank |
Company |
Six-month rate |
1 | Erie | $195 |
2 | USAA | $224 |
3 | Farm Bureau | $251 |
4 | State Farm | $309 |
5 | Auto-Owners | $513 |
Companies with the lowest rates for a full coverage insurance
Rank |
Company |
Six-month rate |
1 | USAA | $644 |
2 | Erie | $806 |
3 | State Farm | $812 |
4 | Farm Bureau | $871 |
5 | American Family | $1,067 |
A full-coverage policy includes collision and comprehensive insurance, which protects you against vehicle damage as well as legal liability for hurting or injuring other drivers.
Customers who qualify for Erie's rate lock program can prevent premium increases that could cause rates to rise over time. This is a one-of-a-kind service in which customers' costs will not increase until they move to a new region or alter where they park their car, add or remove someone from their insurance, or add or remove a car.
Furthermore, despite its modest size, Erie provides the same sorts of reductions as bigger national insurers. These include discounts for holding several policies, a car with anti-lock brakes or anti-theft technology, and discounts for young and older drivers.
Erie also received top grades for insurance alternatives, since it provides pet coverage, free accident forgiveness, free vanishing deductibles, and roadside assistance to its clients, offering them a level of freedom rarely found even among the largest insurers.
The most significant disadvantage of Erie is that it is only accessible in the following areas:
•The District of Columbia.
•Illinois
•Indiana
•Kentucky
•Maryland
•New York City
•North Carolina (NC)
•Ohio
•Pennsylvania
•Tennessee
•Virginia
•West Virginia (WV)
•Wisconsin
If you are not qualified for USAA and some of these smaller insurance firms are not available in your area, we recommend State Farm as the most affordable overall insurance provider and a good location to start your comparison shopping.
State Farm Is The Cheapest Auto Insurance Company After An Accident.
When we analyzed the various vehicle insurance companies we researched, we discovered that State Farm boosts car insurance premiums the least if a driver is involved in a recent at-fault collision. State Farm's average rates after an accident jumped by 24%, from $812 to $1,010, the smallest rate rise of any large firm we examined. Insurers raised premiums by 42 percent on average.
Despite raising premiums by 25% after an accident, a greater penalty than State Farm, Erie remained the cheapest insurance for a motorist with an at-fault accident on his record. However, vehicle insurance prices vary widely, and the fact that State Farm penalizes drivers the least suggests that it is a smart place to start for buyers with an accident history seeking low-cost insurance.
Other advantages of State Farm include its excellent customer service and claims handling.
•According to our study of existing customers, the majority of clients are satisfied with the way State Farm treats them.
•73% of respondents said they were highly happy with the insurer's most recent claims procedure.
Company |
Clean record |
One crash |
Rate hike |
Erie | $1,612 | $2,010 | 24% |
State Farm | $1,623 | $2,020 | 25% |
Farm Bureau | $1,742 | $2,325 | 33% |
Geico | $2,017 | $3,194 | 58% |
American Family | $2,135 | $3,260 | 53% |
Auto-Owners | $2,192 | $2,750 | 25% |
Nationwide | $2,201 | $3,292 | 50% |
MetLife | $2,379 | $4,003 | 68% |
Travelers | $3,002 | $3,610 | 20% |
Farmers | $3,582 | $5,031 | 40% |
Allstate | $3,585 | $5,488 | 53% |
USAA | $1,288 | $1,824 | 42% |
Rates are for a 6-month full coverage policy that includes comprehensive, collision, and state-mandated liability insurance.
USAA is the cheapest car insurance company for military members.
You may be qualified for USAA vehicle insurance if you are a military member, veteran, or a family member of one. If this is the case, we discovered that USAA, not Erie, is the cheapest insurer in the country on average.
In reality, USAA is by far the most affordable company. While the average cost of basic coverage is just $27 less than Farm Bureau for six-month insurance, Farm Bureau policies sometimes demand membership dues, which may range from $20 to $50 per year.
Insurer |
Average six-month rate |
USAA | $224 |
Farm Bureau | $251 |
Average of all insurers | $449 |
USAA is distinguished by more than just its low cost: it also has one of the greatest customer service reputations in the business. According to our study of existing insurance customers, 62% rated their customer service as outstanding, and 78% were highly happy with their most recent claim. Both of these values ranked first among all qualified insurers in the poll.
Read about USAA's insurance options for additional details.
Metromile Is The Cheapest Car Insurance For Low-Mileage Drivers.
If you find yourself getting out of the car more often than not, a pay-per-mile vehicle insurance business like Metromile may be the best option for you.
Metromile was one of the first firms in the United States to base premiums mostly on mileage. When shopping with Metromile, how much driving is too much? In general, drivers should drive less than 7,500 miles per year for Metromile to be a decent price.
Metromile's main disadvantage is that it is only offered in eight states: Arizona, California, Illinois, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Washington.
Geico Has The Cheapest Car Insurance For People With Bad Credit.
Geico was the cheapest auto insurance company overall for drivers with bad credit, with an average premium of $1,193.
According to our findings, when an identical driver had a low credit score rather than an exceptional credit score, he only paid 39 percent more with Geico. Among our sample insurers, this was the third-lowest percentage rise.
Company |
Poor credit |
Very good credit |
Rate hike |
Geico | $1,193 | $722 | 65% |
Farm Bureau | $1,226 | $684 | 79% |
Nationwide | $1,333 | $840 | 59% |
State Farm | $1,340 | $477 | 181% |
American Family | $1,353 | $778 | 74% |
Auto-Owners | $1,417 | $663 | 114% |
Erie | $1,492 | $558 | 167% |
Farmers | $1,783 | $1,098 | 62% |
Allstate | $1,926 | $1,138 | 69% |
Travelers | $1,997 | $785 | 154% |
USAA | $968 | $498 | 94% |
Rates are for a full coverage policy purchased by our selected sample driver.
Our sample insurers charged 104 percent more if a motorist had low credit rather than excellent credit, thus boosting your credit score is a wonderful method to save money on your insurance coverage.
How To Find The Most Affordable Car Insurance Coverage
To discover the lowest vehicle insurance for you, you should generally follow two steps.
•Make certain that you are looking for the right quantity of auto insurance coverage.
•Compare rates from several insurance, including our best picks. When you're out shopping, make sure to take advantage of any and all available discounts.
Knowing how much vehicle insurance you need is a crucial first step in getting adequately priced car insurance because:
•You don't want to overpay for coverage that isn't essential.
•However, you should obtain enough coverage to meet legal requirements and adequately cover your risk.
•Finally, in order to perform accurate pricing comparisons among insurers, you'll need to specify your suitable coverage limits.
Understanding your present economic conditions, how different forms of coverage interact, and your state regulations are all important factors in determining how much vehicle insurance you require.
The table below provides a fast overview of the various forms of vehicle insurance coverage, whether you need them, and how much you should have.
Personal injury liability
Liability for property damage
Coverage for uninsured and underinsured motorists
Comprehensive and collision insurance
Medical payments or personal injury protection (PIP)
Except for Florida, every state requires it.
Every state requires it.
22 states need it.
If you have a car loan or lease, this is required.
In 14 states, it is required.
Accident limitations that are near to your net worth
Accident limitations that are near to your net worth If you don't have PIP or collision insurance, your per-accident
limitations will be close to your net worth.
If your automobile is worth more than $2,000, this is a must-have.
If you don't have health insurance or have large deductibles or copays, this is a good option.
The amount of coverage you require will be determined by your financial condition. For example, high-net-worth persons should obtain liability limits that are proportional to their net worth, which would almost certainly exceed the state-mandated minimums.
Now that you've determined how much car insurance you require, shop around among insurers and take advantage of any available discounts.
When you've determined how much coverage you need, it's time to shop around for auto insurance providers. Even if you choose the same coverage levels with two different insurers, one company may be substantially cheaper for you based on how it calculates its rates.
Using internet comparison tools, it is now easier than ever to compare insurance prices. However, you should consult with an insurance representative to ensure that you receive the most accurate price available
You can find out whether you qualify for reductions that aren't available through the online quotation tool by speaking with an agent. Car insurance discounts are often classified into four types:
•Driver safety discount: Lower rates for having a clean driving record or attending defensive driving classes.
•Driver status discount: Provides a discount for lifestyle factors that insurers reward with lower premiums. These can range from incentives, such as a student receiving discounts for high grades, to uncontrollable aspects, such as a senior discount for individuals of a specific age.
•Policy discount: Savings granted for purchasing additional goods or coverage from a certain insurer. The most typical sort of discount is a house and auto bundle, in which you save significantly by purchasing home and car insurance from the same insurer.
•Safe car discount: If your vehicle has features that boost its safety, such as anti-theft technology, you may be eligible for a discount.
You're Probably Overpaying For Your Insurance Policy.
According to Value Penguin, a driver seeking a state-mandated insurance policy — the minimal coverage necessary — overpays by an average of $330 per year. When extrapolated throughout the country, this means that Americans overpay for vehicle insurance by over $37 billion every year.
Once you've determined how much coverage you want, the easiest approach to locate low-cost auto insurance is to compare rates from several organizations.
Most firms provide quote tools that can be used to obtain automobile insurance prices, so this may be done online. Additionally, if you prefer to engage with a real person when shopping for auto insurance, you might speak with an independent insurance agent who can assist you in comparing prices from several providers.
Questions And Answers
Who Has The Lowest Car Insurance Rates?
USAA had the lowest rates among national insurers, at $37 per month, with State Farm coming in second at $52 per month. Erie, at $33 per month, and Farm Bureau, at $42 per month, the lowest area insurance.
What Is The Lowest Cost Online Car Insurance?
USAA, and State Farm were among the most affordable firms that allowed you to acquire rates and buy a policy online. Because you won't have to pay agency fees and you may frequently obtain extra savings for buying online, getting auto insurance online is typically less expensive than working with an agent.
How Can I Lower My Car Insurance Costs?
The most effective strategy to save money on vehicle insurance is to compare rates from various companies. Make sure you take into account all of the factors that go into your quotation, like coverage amounts, deductibles, discounts, and extra costs. And don't only obtain estimates from huge national carriers; regional businesses like Erie, Farm Bureau, and American Family may have some of the best prices if you live in one of their service states.
What Is The Lowest Cost Car Insurance?
The lowest sort of automobile insurance is state minimum liability coverage. On average, liability-only insurance is $1,500 less expensive than a full-coverage policy. If your automobile isn't worth much and you own it completely, switching to liability-only coverage might be an excellent way to save money.
Is Getting The Cheapest Car Insurance A Good Idea?
It all depends on what you're willing to give up in exchange for the lowest price. Consider how much extra you'd have to pay out of cash if you increase your deductible or cut your coverage maximums, for example. Alternatively, if you select a provider with a reputation for poor claims processing, consider how long you can afford to be without a car or pay for a rental car while you wait for the repair check to arrive in the mail.